The rise of independence feelings in Catalonia and Scotland. A longitudinal study on the profile of independence in the beginning of the 21st century

  1. Merino, Javier Antón 1
  1. 1 Universidad de Burgos

    Universidad de Burgos

    Burgos, España


  2. 2 Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

    Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

    Madrid, España


Review of Nationalities

ISSN: 2084-848X

Year of publication: 2020

Volume: 10

Issue: 1

Pages: 57-75

Type: Article

DOI: 10.2478/PN-2020-0005 GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openOpen access editor

More publications in: Review of Nationalities

Sustainable development goals


Abstract The following article aims to make headway on the knowledge related to the elements that explain the steep increase of secessionist nationalism during the 21 st century in the peripheral territories of plurinational Western long-established democracies, such as the ones existing in the United Kingdom and Spain. In order to do so, we will be focusing on the quick change observed in the preferences as to the state territorial organization in Catalonia and Scotland. Through the usage of the logistic regression technique, a longitudinal analysis will be carried out to analyze the principal characteristics of the Catalonian and Scottish independence profile throughout the period comprehended between 1999 and 2016.

Bibliographic References

  • Aguilera de Prat, C.R. (2002) Partidos y estrategias nacionalistas en Cataluña, Escocia y Flandes, Valencia.
  • Álvarez Pereira B., Portos M., Vourdas, J. (2018), Waving goodbye? The determinants ofautonomism and secessionism in Western Europe, “Regional Studies”, No. 52(2), pp. 197-211, DOI:
  • Balcells A. (1996), Catalan Nationalism, London, DOI:
  • Bel G., Cuadras-Morató X., Rodon T. (2019), Crisis? What crisis? Economic recovery and support for independence in Catalonia, “Regional Science Policy and Practice”, No. 11(5), pp. 833-848, DOI:
  • Berelson B., Lazarfeld P., Gaudet H. (1968), The people’s choice: how the voter makes up his mind in a presidential campaign, New York.
  • Berelson B., Lazarfeld P., McPhee W. (1954), Voting: a study of lector formation in a presidential campaign, Chicago.
  • Bourne A.K. (2014), Europeanization and Secession: The Cases of Catalonia and Scotland, “Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe”, No. 13(3), pp. 94-120.
  • Boylan B.M. (2015), In pursuit of independence: The political economy of Catalonia’s secessionist movement, “Nations and Nationalism”, No. 21(4), pp. 761-785, DOI:
  • Brand J., Mitchell J., Surridge P. (1993), Identity and the vote: Class and nationality in Scotland, “British Elections and Parties Yearbook”, No. 3(1), pp. 143-157, DOI:
  • Burg S.L. (2015), Identity, Grievances, and Popular Mobilization for Independence in Catalonia, “Nationalism and Ethnic Politics”, No. 21, pp. 289-312, DOI:
  • Cetrá D., Harvey M. (2019), Explaining accommodation and resistance to demands for independence referendums in the UK and Spain, “Nations and Nationalism”, No. 25(2), pp. 607-629, DOI:
  • Chernyha L.T., Burg S.L. (2012), Accounting for the Effects of Identity on Political Behavior, “Comparative Political Studies”, No. 45(6), pp. 774-803, DOI:
  • Clark D. (2019), Religious identification in Scotland in 2018, [access on: 01.05.2020].
  • Colomé G. (2017), La Cataluña insurgente, Barcelona.
  • Colomer J.M. (2008), Empire-, State- and Nation-Building and Deconstructing in Spain, “Multinational State Building: building democratic states on national diversity”, pp. 357-379.
  • Conversi D. (1997), The Basques, the Catalans, and Spain : alternative routes to nationalist mobilisation, Hurst.
  • Cortizas C.N., Antunes S.F. (2016), ‘yes Scotland’, Bruselas.
  • Crameri K. (2014), ‘Goodbye, Spain?’ The question of independence for Catalonia, Sussex Academic Press.
  • Crameri K. (2015), Political Power and Civil Counterpower: The Complex Dynamics of the Catalan Independence Movement, “Nationalism and Ethnic Politics”, No. 21(1), pp. 104-120, DOI:
  • Dalle Mulle E. (2015), The Nationalism of the Rich: Discourses and Strategies of Separatist Parties in Catalonia, Flanders, Scotland and Padania, Geneva, DOI:
  • Dardanelli P. (2019), Conceptualizing, Measuring and Mapping State Structures - with an Application to Western Europe, 1950-2015, “Publius: The Journal of Federalism”, No. 49(2), pp. 271-298, DOI:
  • Devine T.M. (2008), Scotland and the Union 1707-2007, Edinburgh.
  • Díez Medrano J. (1999), Naciones divididas: clase, política y nacionalismo en el País Vasco y Cataluña, Madrid.
  • Guibernau M. (2013), Secessionism in Catalonia: After Democracy, “Ethnopolitics”, No. 12(4), pp. 368-393, DOI:
  • Guibernau M. (2014), Prospects for an Independent Catalonia, “International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society”, No. 27(1), pp. 5-23, DOI:
  • Hastings A. (2000), La construcción de las nacionalidades. Etnicidad, religión y nacionalismo, Madrid.
  • Hechter M. (1976), Internal Colonialism: The Celtic Fringe in British National Development, Londres.
  • Hechter M. (2000), Nationalism and Rationality, “Journal ofWorld-Systems Research”, No. 35(1), pp. 308-329, DOI:
  • Hechter M. (2001), Containing Nationalism, Oxford, DOI:
  • Hooghe L. et al. (2016), Measuring Regional Authority, Oxford, DOI:
  • Horowitz, D. L. (1985), Ethnic groups in conflict. Beerkeley.
  • Instituto de Ciencias Políticas y Sociales (2020), Sondeo de Opinión Cataluña. Base de datos integrada 1991-2016, [access on: 02.04.2020].
  • Keating M. (1996), Naciones contra el Estado. El nacionalismode Cataluña, Quebeec y Escocia, Barcelona.
  • Keating M. (2012), La independencia de Escocia, Valencia.
  • Keating M. (2017), Debating Scotland, Debating Scotland, Oxford, DOI:
  • Keating M., Wilson A. (2009), Renegotiating the State of Autonomies: Statute Reform and Multilevel Politics in Spain, “West European Politics”, No. 32(3), pp. 536-558, DOI:
  • LeDuc, L. (1977), Canadian Attitudes Towards Quebec Independence, “Public Opinion Quarterly”, No. 41(3), pp. 347-355, DOI:
  • León S. (2011), Who is responsible for what? Clarity of responsibilities in multilevel states: The case of Spain, “European Journal of Political Research”, No. 50(1), pp. 80-109, DOI:
  • Lereuz J. (1983), L ‘Ecosse. Une nation sans état, Lille.
  • Leyland P. (2016), The Constitution of the United Kingdom. A contextual Analysis. The constitution of the United Kingdom (3a), Worcester.
  • Liñeira R. (2011), ‘Less at Stake’ or a Different Game? Regional Elections in Catalonia and Scotland, “Regional and Federal Studies”, No. 21(3), pp. 283-303, DOI:
  • Liñeira R. (2012), El Estado de las autonomías en la opinión pública: Preferencias, conocimiento y voto, Barcelona.
  • Liñeira R., Cetrá D. (2015), The Independence Case in Comparative Perspective, “The Political Quarterly”, No. 86(2), pp. 257-264, DOI:
  • Liñeira R., Henderson A., Delaney L. (2017), Voters’ Response to the Campaign: evidence from survey, [in:] Debating Scotland, edit. M. Keating, Oxford, pp. 165-190, DOI:
  • Liñeira R., Vallés J.M. (2014), Differential Abstention in Catalonia and the Community of Madrid: A Socio-political Explanation of an Urban Phenomenon, “Revista Española de Investigaciones Sociologicas”, No. 146(June), pp. 69-92, DOI:
  • Linz J.J. (2008), Obras escogidas. Vol. 2: Nación Estado y lengua, Madrid.
  • Llera F.J., Leonisio R., Pérez Castaños S. (2017), The influence of the elites’ discourse in political attitudes: evidence from the Basque Country, “National Identities”, No. 19(4), pp. 367-393, DOI:
  • Martínez-Herrera E. (2010), Federalism and ethnic conflict management: Rival hypotheses, the attitudinal missing link and comparative evidence, “New Directions in Federalism Studies”, pp. 141-156.
  • McHarg A. et al. (2016), The Scottish Independence Referendum. Constitutional and Political Implications, Croydon.
  • Medina L., Rico G. (2017), The plebiscitary moment in Catalonia: Voters and parties through the independence challenge (2012-2017), “Working Papers”, No. 364.
  • Miley T.J. (2007), Against the Thesis of the ‘Civic Nation: The Case of Catalonia in Contemporary Spain, “Nationalism and Ethnic Politics”, No. 13(1), pp. 1-37, DOI:
  • Miley T.J. (2008), Who Are the Catalans ? Language, Identity and Assimilation in Contemporary Catalonia, “Working Papers”, No. 158.
  • Miley T.J., Garvía R. (2019), Conflict in Catalonia: A Sociological Approximation, “Genealogy”, No. 3(4), p. 56, DOI:
  • Montero J.R., Font J. (1989), El voto dual en Catalunya: Dimensiones, sujetos y factores, Barcelona.
  • Montero J.R., Font J. (1991), El Voto Dual en Cataluña: Lealtady Transferencia de Votos en las Elecciones Autonómicas, “Revista de Estudios Políticos (Nueva Época)”, No. (73), pp. 7-34.
  • Mooney G., Scott G. (2015), The 2014 Scottish independence debate: questions of social welfare and social justice, “Journal of Poverty and Social Justice”, No. 23(1), pp. 5-16, DOI: /10.1332/175982715X14231434073599.
  • Moreno L. (1988), Identificatión dual y autonomía polítical los casos de escocia y cataluña, “Revista Española de Investigaciones Sociológical’, No. 42, pp. 155-174, DOI:
  • Moreno L. (1995), Escocia, natión y razón: dos milenios de política y sociedad, Madrid.
  • Moreno L. (2008), La federalizatión de España: Poder político y territorio, Salamanca.
  • Moreno L., Lecours A. (2009), Nacionalismo y democracia : dicotomías, complementariedades, oposiciones, Madrid.
  • Mota F. (2015), La descentralización política en España, [in:] Informe españa 2 0 15, edit. Fundación Encuentro, Madrid.
  • Muñoz J., Tormos R. (2015), Economic expectations and support for secession in Catalonia: Between causality and rationalization, “European Political Science Review”, No. 7(2), pp. 315-341, DOI:
  • Muro D., Vidal G., Vlaskamp M.C. (2020), Does international recognition matter? Support for unilateral secession in Catalonia and Scotland, “Nations and Nationalism”, No. 26(1), pp. 176-196, DOI:
  • Muro D., Vlaskamp M.C. (2016), How do prospects of EU membership influence support for secession? A survey experiment in Catalonia and Scotland, “West European Politics”, No. 39(6), pp. 1115-1138, DOI:
  • Nagel K.-J. (2014), ¿Del autonomismo al independentismo? En vías de interpretar el giro reciente del nacionalismo Catalán, [in:] Naciones y estado: la cuestión española, edit. Universidad de Valencia, Valencia, pp. 325-352.
  • Nagel, K.-J. (2015), Catalonia’s struggle for self-determination: from regionalism to independence?, [in:] Nationalism and intra-state conflicts in the postcolonial world, Londres, pp. 385-401.
  • Nairn T. (1990), The modern Janus: nationalism in the modern world, London.
  • NatCen Social Research (2017), Scottish Social Attitudes Survey (SSAS), [access on: 02.04.2020].
  • O’Brian C.C. (1988), God land: reflections on religion and nationalism, Cambridge.
  • Olivieri V.M. (2015), Sub-state nationalism in Spain: primers and triggers of identity politics in Catalonia and the Basque Country, “Ethnic and Racial Studies”, No. 38.DOI:
  • Ortega Villodres C., Trujillo Cerezo J.M. (2017), Análisis geográfico de los resultados del voto del 27-S, [in:] Cataluña en Proceso. Las elecciones autonómicas de 2015, edit. J.M. Rivera Otero, J. Montabes Pereira, N. Lagares Díez, Valencia, pp. 71-103.
  • Pallarés F., Font J. (1994), Las elecciones autonómicas en Cataluña (1980-1992), [in:] Comportamiento político y electoral, pp. 221-274.
  • Pammett J.H., LeDuc L. (2001), Sovereignty, leadership and voting in the Quebec referendums, “Electoral Studies”, No. 20(2), pp. 265-280, DOI:
  • Parrado, S. (2013), Reino Unido, [in:] Gobiernosy Administraciones Públicas en perspectiva comparada, Valencia, pp. 227-262.
  • Pattie C., Johnston R. (2017), Stickingto the Union?Nationalism, inequality and political disaffection and the geography of Scotland’s 2014 independence referendum, “Regional and Federal Studies”, No. 27(1), pp. 83-96, DOI:
  • Pérez-Nievas S., Bonet E. (2006), Identidades regionales y revindicación de autogobierno el et- norregionalismo en el voto a partidos de Bélgica, España y Reino Unido, “Revista española de ciencia política”, No. 15, pp. 123-161.
  • Pérez-Nievas S., Rama Caamaño J. (2017), Las bases socialesy actitudinales del voto nacionalista en España: Cataluña, Galicia y el País Vasco, [in:] Informe España 2018, edit. Universidad Pontificia Comillas, Madrid, pp. 301-364.
  • Pérez Castaños S., García Rabadán J. (2019), La cultura político federal en España. Cambios y consecuencias ante el reto catalán/Federal Political Culture in Spain. Changes in Response to the Catalonian Challenge, “Revista Española de Investigadones Sociológicas”, pp. 37-56, DOI:
  • Porta della D., O’Connor F., Portos M. (2019), The framing of secessionism in the neo-liberal crisis, [in:] Between Democracy and Law, New York, pp. 155-172, DOI:
  • Porta della D., Portos M. (2020), A bourgeois story? The class basis of Catalan independentism, “Territory, Politics, Governance”, pp. 1-21, DOI:
  • Riba C. (2000), Voto dual y abstención diferencial. Un estudio sobre el comportamiento electoral en cataluña, “Reis”, No. 91(91), p. 59, DOI:
  • Riera Sagrera P. (2011), La abstención diferencial en el País Vasco y Cataluña, “Revista de Estudios Políticos”, No. (154).
  • Rodon T., Guinjoan M. (2018), When the context matters: Identity, secession and the spatial dimension in Catalonia, “Political Geography”, No.63, pp. 75-87, DOI:
  • Rokkan S., Urwin D.W. (1983), Economy, Territory, Identity. Politics of West European Peripheries, Londres.
  • Schrijver F.J. (2006), Regionalism after regionalisation Spain, France and the United Kingdom, Amsterdam.
  • Scottish Government (2013), Scotland’s Future: Your Guide to an Independent Scotland, Edinburgh.
  • Serrano I. (2013), Just a Matter of Identity? Support for Independence in Catalonia, “Regional & Federal Studies”, No. 23(5), pp. 523-545, DOI:
  • Simon P., Orriols L. (2016), Language, National Identity, and Vote Choice in Catalonia, 1984-2015, Filadelfia.
  • Tilley J., Heath A. (2007), The decline of British national pride, “The British Journal of Sociology”, No. 58(4), pp. 661-678, DOI:
  • Torcal M., Mota F. (2014), The role of political parties in shaping citizens’political preferences for the territorial organization of the state: the Spanish case, “European Political Science Review”, No. 6(3), pp. 477-502, DOI:
  • Zwet van der A. (2015), Operationalising national identity: The cases of the Scottish National Party and Frisian National Party, “Nations and Nationalism”, No. 21 (1), pp. 62-82, DOI: